Troy versus homers illiad essay

These differences are what are to be discussed today from within the film and the Iliad: He too was supposed to survive the war and return home to Greece to be killed by his wife Clytemnestra. Hector slits Achilles throat then removes his helmet to find that it is not Achilles like everyone believed it to be but Patroclus.

On the other hand, there are some differences between the movie and the film that are quite significant and do not permit to define the film as a real epic. In the film Chrysies has merely seemed to disappear from being and Briseis is now a cousin of Hector and Paris.

In fact, it is really hard to remain untouched by the great power and human genius when one looks at the creations of ancient Greeks, which were actually unprotected in face of the wildlife and nature.

Agamemnon consults the prophet and learns he must return his prize but in return he demands Briseis. The actors in the movie wear clothes typical to the epoch of ancient Greece and the period of the Trojan war. Get Full Essay Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Within the Iliad, the war upon Troy lasted for 10, presumably very long years before the wooden horse ploy was developed and put into play, this is very different from what the film Troy depicts, which only has the war last for 17 days before the walls of Troy are breached from within inside.

This characteristic upset me as Peterson objective in this film was to portray the Greeks in an accurate was utilizing the Iliad as his get downing point yet he has failed to make so.

The Iliad starts 9 years after the beginning of the Trojan War with the Achaean Greek army raiding the town of Chryse and taking two women, Chrysies and Briseis. This plan backfires and Patroclus ends up dead due to Apollo knocking him to the ground and Hector slaying him.

His body however does not become tarnished as the Gods have put a protective spell on it. We then see a clip of Helen attempting to leave Troy as she believes if she returns to Menelaus it will prevent more lives from being lost.

As dawn approaches on the battle field we see Achilles riding into battle which shocks everyone but raises their spirits, unbeknown to everyone it is actually Patroclus wearing Achilles armour.

However in Troy, Achillies can be seen as a stronger warrior because he could still defeat everyone without having been dipped into the Styx even if they did have Achillies die by being shot in the ankle.

Whatever the reason, the lack of the gods in Troy left the film with a sour taste in my mouth as i was interested to see how they would portray the gods and how big of a row they would have.

This essay mentions that every warrior has a choice between war and peace, and i agree on this which is shown from the Iliad. This is where the myth of the Trojan horse is intertwined with the story.

Troy Versus Homers Illiad Essay Sample

Choose Type of service. This is a considerable drawback of the movie, if it pretends to be an epic work like the original poem since religion and beliefs of ancient Greeks carefully depicted by Homer constituted a substantial part of their life and culture that made the poem even more significant work that depicted various spheres of life of ancient society, its culture, beliefs, everyday life in historical context.

Essay: Comparison of the Movie Troy and the Iliad

Achilles with his love to fight joins the war against Troy, not believing in what his mother has foretold of his fate. At the same time, the new time needs new ways of the representation of events depicted by Homer. Hector who is now repenting what he has done. The Iliad besides has a proper representation of entombment in comparing to the film ; Homer dedicated a whole book of the Iliad to the ideals of Grecian Burial.

Other gods are also portrayed in the Iliad such as Hermes, who guides King Priam to Achilles tent safely so that he can ask for the return of his son Hectors body while in the movie; King Priam makes the journey by himself. This is due to the absence of the Gods and Goddesses in the film. Achilles filled with his ain fury and stupidity.

These forgotten aspects in the movie really enraged me as Petersons ideals in the movie Troy were to try and accurately show Greek lifestyle and war yet he failed by leaving out a huge aspect which was involved in this, the Gods and Goddesses of Olympus.

Troy Versus Homers Illiad Sample Essay

However both versions do not portray accurate versions of the fight between Menelaus and Paris, nor do they correctly explain why Helen has come to reside in Troy nor does the movie portray the proper burial rights of the Greeks.

As a result, instead of the war that had lasted for ten years, the creators of the movies depict practically a kind of Blitzkrieg, which shows the audience a perfect military operation organized by ancient Greeks that was successfully accomplished within seventeen days.

Homer really emphasized the Gods, including them in all aspects of his books.

Comparison of Troy and Iliad

He weeps over Hectors organic structure before giving it back to Priam and he allows Briseis to return to Troy with him. For instance, probably one of the most important points in this respect is the timeline. I besides hope that he comes to his senses and makes another proper representation of what he wanted to accomplish.

These forgotten aspects in the movie really enraged me as Petersons ideals in the movie Troy were to try and accurately show Greek lifestyle and war yet he failed by leaving out a huge aspect which was involved in this, the Gods and Goddesses of Olympus.

When comparing the film Troy. directed by Wolfgang Petterson. and The Iliad. written by Greek poet Homer we can clearly see that although Petterson has made an first-class movie he has clearly left out certain facets of the Iliad which truly define the narrative. The historical events depicted in Homer’s “Iliad” was traditionally a subject of scientific and literature discussions and the definite answer concerning the extent to which the events depicted by the ancient artist are truthful is still not given.

Troy vs. The Iliad Essays Words | 6 Pages. Troy vs. The Iliad Over the thousands of years that the epic story the Iliad has survived, there has no doubt been some form of alteration to Homer’s original.

Example essay topics, free essays

Below is an essay on "Troy Vs. The Iliad" from Anti Essays, your source for research papers, essays, and term paper examples. Homer’s “The Iliad,” is one of the greatest epic poems of all time because of its perceptive portrayal of man and its epic account of war, duty, honor, and revenge.

Related Documents: Comparison of Troy and the Iliad Essay Essay on Iliad Cover The Iliad Cover Description In the legendary epic “The Iliad” by the poet Homer it is a story which begins in the 9th year of the Trojan War filled.

Essay Troy vs. The Iliad - Troy vs. The Iliad Over the thousands of years that the epic story the Iliad has survived, there has no doubt been some form of alteration to Homer.

Troy versus homers illiad essay
Rated 0/5 based on 96 review
Comparison of Troy and Iliad - Essay